
Fenway Hotel
Best for guests who want historic character, multiple on-site dining options, and event/wedding facilities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored Jazz Age waterfront boutique in Dunedin with on-site restaurants, event venues, and a rooftop bar — a good read for travelers who want history, dining, and easy access to downtown Dunedin. Caprice 306 is a condo-style beach lodging on St. Pete Beach for travelers who prioritize direct beach access and a simple self-catered stay.
Updated

Best for guests who want historic character, multiple on-site dining options, and event/wedding facilities.

Best for travelers who want a private condo on the beach with onsite parking and a pool.
When Fenway Hotel wins: Pick Fenway if you want historic character, on-site restaurants and bars (including a rooftop bar), event spaces, and a walkable downtown Dunedin base with waterfront views.
When Caprice 306 wins: Choose Caprice 306 if your priority is staying directly on St. Pete Beach in a condo layout with a private balcony, onsite (self) parking, and access to a shared pool.
Bottom line: Fenway is a full-service boutique hotel experience focused on dining, events, and historic waterfront appeal; Caprice 306 is a straightforward beachfront condo option better suited to travelers focused on beach time and a private condo setup.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | Caprice 306 |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic waterfront boutique with event spaces, on-site restaurants and a rooftop bar. | Condo-style beachfront lodging offering private condo accommodations and a balcony. |
| Location | Dunedin on St. Joseph Sound, close to downtown and the Pinellas Trail. | On St. Pete Beach, directly on the beach and near Upham Beach and Corey Ave. |
| Size (rooms) | 83 guest rooms and suites. | Not published |
| Ages / entry policy | Hotel welcomes children of all ages; minimum age to check in is 21. | No adults-only policy; minimum check-in age listed as 25 on supplier listing. |
| Pools & outdoor | One heated outdoor pool just off the lobby with sun loungers. | Heated swimming pool onsite; private balcony in the condo. |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar (21+), Parlor Bar, Room 27 private dining. | Self-catered condo — no on-property signature restaurants listed. |
| Spa & wellness | Fitness center (24-hour); no on-site spa (local spas nearby). | Not published |
| Parking | Valet parking (overnight fee for guests; complimentary for restaurant/event patrons). | Free self parking onsite. |
| Known for | Historic Jazz Age hotel, weddings and events, waterfront views and rooftop bar. | Beachfront condo on St. Pete Beach close to Core y Ave and local attractions. |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in 4:00 PM, check-out 11:00 AM. | Check-in begins 4:00 PM, check-out 10:00 AM. |
Fenway Hotel sits on St. Joseph Sound in downtown Dunedin near the Pinellas Trail and marina.
Best if you want a walkable downtown base with historic waterfront character and easy local trail access.
Caprice 306 is located at 6950 Beach Plaza on St. Pete Beach, placing you directly on the sand near core attractions.
Best if your primary priority is immediate beach access and staying in St. Pete Beach.
Fenway Hotel offers boutique guest rooms and suites with period character and modern amenities.
Choose Fenway for boutique-style rooms inside a restored 1920s landmark with modern conveniences.
Caprice 306 is offered as a condo unit with multiple beds and a private balcony.
Choose Caprice 306 when you want a private condo layout and the option to self-cater on the beach.
Fenway Hotel provides several dedicated dining and drinking venues on-property.
Fenway works well for travelers who value on-site dining options and an active evening scene without leaving the property.
Caprice 306 is a condo with no signature on-site restaurants listed in the supplier facts.
Caprice 306 fits travelers who prefer cooking or eating out locally rather than relying on hotel dining.
Fenway's signature outdoor amenity is its heated outdoor pool and waterfront lawn.
Fenway combines a hotel pool with waterfront sightlines and outdoor event lawn space.
Caprice 306's main shared amenities include a heated pool and direct beach access.
Caprice 306 is geared toward guests who want simple shared pool access plus immediate beach steps away.
Fenway offers 24-hour fitness and nearby spa options, plus an active nightlife with rooftop and bar venues.
Fenway gives you fitness access and local wellness partners plus on-site evening bars for a social night out.
Caprice 306 provides basic condo amenities; local St. Pete Beach nightlife and wellness options are nearby.
Caprice 306 keeps things simple on property while leaving nightlife and spa choices to nearby businesses on St. Pete Beach.

Fenway — HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, and Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar give you multiple on-site dining and evening options.

Caprice 306 — the condo is on St. Pete Beach with a private balcony and immediate beach access.

Fenway — numerous indoor/outdoor venues and nearly 11,500 sq ft of event space for ceremonies and receptions.

Caprice 306 — condo setup and free self parking make longer or more independent beach stays straightforward.
Fenway Hotel — it sits within an 8–10 minute walk of downtown Dunedin's restaurants, breweries, and galleries.
Caprice 306 — it's a condo on St. Pete Beach, steps from the sand and near Corey Ave and Upham Beach.
Fenway does not have an on-site spa (local spas are nearby). Caprice 306's supplier listing does not publish an on-site spa.
Fenway welcomes children of all ages (check-in minimum age is 21). Caprice 306 is not adults-only per its listing; supplier info shows a 25-year minimum to check in.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·