
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want Jazz Age history, event/wedding space, and a lively on-site restaurant and rooftop bar.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored 1920s Jazz Age landmark in Dunedin with waterfront lawns, a heated outdoor pool and a rooftop bar — read this if you want a historic, all-ages boutique hotel near downtown Dunedin. The Gemma by Brightwild is a high-end Clearwater Beach boutique-style property with individually decorated guesthouses and private pools — read this if you prioritize being steps from Clearwater Beach and room-level privacy.
Updated · about 3.1 miles (5 km) apart

Best for travelers who want Jazz Age history, event/wedding space, and a lively on-site restaurant and rooftop bar.

Best for guests who want a high-end, beach-front Clearwater Beach base with private pools and a small, boutique-house feel.
When Fenway Hotel wins: pick Fenway if you want a historic landmark property with sizable event and wedding spaces, a full-service steakhouse (HEW Parlor & Chophouse), and a rooftop bar experience — plus easy access to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail.
When The Gemma wins: choose The Gemma by Brightwild if you want to be on Clearwater Beach, prefer individually decorated guesthouses with private pools/hot tubs, and plan to spend most of your time on the sand or in a private villa-like room.
Bottom line: Fenway is the choice for history, restaurants, rooftop evenings and larger event capability; The Gemma is the choice for beachfront proximity and private, villa-style rooms. Your pick depends on whether you prioritize Dunedin’s historic waterfront and social dining versus direct Clearwater Beach access and private accommodation features.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | The Gemma by Brightwild |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Jazz Age boutique with event focus and social bars | High-end Clearwater Beach boutique with villa-style guestrooms |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront on St. Joseph Sound; walkable to downtown Dunedin | On Clearwater Beach, steps from the sand and Pier 60 area |
| Size | 83 rooms and suites | 4 individually decorated guestrooms (guesthouse model) |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; check-in minimum 21 | All ages welcome (not adults-only per supplier listing) |
| Pools & hot tubs | One heated outdoor pool near the lobby; pool garden event space | Outdoor pool plus private in-room pools and private hot tubs in guestrooms |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse (steakhouse), Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 speakeasy | Not published |
| Wellness & fitness | 24-hour fitness center on-site; no full-service spa on property (nearby spas listed) | Health/beauty spa nearby listed; in-room amenities include memory foam beds and premium bedding |
| Event & wedding capacity | Multiple indoor/outdoor venues (nearly 11,500 sq ft across 8 rooms); lawns for large ceremonies | Wedding services available but limited event-space detail in listing |
| Parking & arrival | Valet parking only for guests (fee for overnight); complimentary valet for restaurant/event patrons | Free self parking and on-site covered/uncovered parking mentioned |
| Connectivity | Free Wi‑Fi; Marriott Bonvoy benefits when booking direct | Free WiFi; smart-lock contactless arrival with virtual front desk |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound in historic Dunedin, close to downtown dining, the Pinellas Trail and nearby barrier islands.
Fenway is better if you want walkable town access plus a quieter Dunedin waterfront base rather than beachfront.
The Gemma is a Clearwater Beach beachfront property a short walk from Pier 60 and Beach Walk.
The Gemma is the clear pick if your priority is staying directly on Clearwater Beach and walking to Pier 60.
Fenway offers 83 rooms and suites inside a restored 1927 hotel with standard boutique-hotel room types.
Fenway works for guests who want traditional hotel rooms and suites within a larger historic property.
The Gemma lists a small set of individually decorated guesthouses, each with distinct names and private-feel amenities.
The Gemma is for travelers who prefer a villa/guesthouse feel and in-room or private-pool features.
Fenway has multiple on-site dining and drinking venues with clearly published hours and reservation options.
If on-site restaurants and a rooftop bar matter, Fenway gives clear, full-service dining options and event-ready food spaces.
The Gemma listing highlights in-room kitchens and concierge services but does not publish signature on-site restaurants in the supplier facts.
Choose The Gemma if you plan to self-cater or dine locally on Clearwater Beach; Fenway is stronger for formal on-site dining.
Fenway has one heated outdoor pool just outside the lobby and large waterfront lawns used for events.
Fenway’s pool and lawns emphasize social spaces and events rather than private pool amenities.
The Gemma emphasizes private-pool amenities and direct beach access as its stand-out features.
The Gemma is best for travelers who want beach access plus private or room-level pools and water-sports options.
Fenway provides 24-hour fitness access, nightlife via its rooftop bar and local downtown evenings within walking distance.
Fenway balances daytime fitness and evening socializing on property while keeping nightlife walkable and low-key in town.
The Gemma supports active beach days, on-site recreation and a quieter in-room retreat in the evenings.
Pick The Gemma if your evenings will be beach sunsets or private time in your guesthouse; pick Fenway for on-site bar-driven evenings.

Fenway — multiple indoor/outdoor venues and large lawn capacities make it suited for weddings and larger events.

The Gemma — beachfront location and easy access to Pier 60 put you steps from sand and sunset programming.

Fenway — HEW Parlor & Chophouse plus the Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar and Parlor Bar provide multiple dining and drinking options.

The Gemma — individually decorated guestrooms with private pools/hot tubs and in-room kitchens suit privacy-minded travelers.
The Gemma is on Clearwater Beach; Fenway is in Dunedin about a 3.1-mile (5 km) drive from the Pier 60/Clearwater Beach area.
No. Fenway welcomes families and children of all ages; The Gemma’s supplier listing also indicates it is not adults-only.
Fenway has several clearly published on-site venues (HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Parlor Bar, Room 27). The Gemma listing does not publish a signature on-site restaurant.
The Gemma is beachfront. Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound and provides waterfront lawns and easy access to nearby barrier-island beaches but is not directly on Clearwater Beach.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·