
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want small-city waterfront charm, historic architecture, and a compact waterfront boutique experience with character-led dining and events.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored Jazz Age boutique hotel on Dunedin’s waterfront that will appeal to travelers who want historic character, small-city waterfront access, and family-friendly service. The Tampa EDITION is a high-profile luxury lifestyle hotel in Water Street Tampa for travelers who want downtown Tampa access, branded luxury amenities, and a full-service spa.
Updated · about 28 km apart

Best for travelers who want small-city waterfront charm, historic architecture, and a compact waterfront boutique experience with character-led dining and events.

Best for travelers who want a contemporary luxury lifestyle stay in downtown Tampa with multiple on-site restaurants, a full-service spa, and branded EDITION amenities.
When Fenway Hotel wins: choose Fenway if you prioritize a historic Jazz Age building, waterfront access to Caladesi and Honeymoon Islands, a smaller, more intimate property (83 rooms), and easy access to Dunedin’s walkable downtown and local trails.
When The Tampa EDITION wins: pick The Tampa EDITION for a downtown Tampa base close to Tampa Riverwalk and the arena, a larger modern luxury property (about 172 rooms) with a full-service spa, multiple restaurants/bars, and the scale and services associated with the EDITION brand.
Bottom line: Fenway suits travelers seeking boutique, historic waterfront character and family-friendly access to nearby beaches; The Tampa EDITION suits travelers seeking contemporary downtown luxury, more on-site F&B and spa facilities, and proximity to Tampa’s urban attractions.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | The Tampa EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Jazz Age boutique, small-city waterfront character | Contemporary luxury lifestyle hotel with branded EDITION design |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront, walkable to downtown Dunedin and Pinellas Trail | Water Street/Channelside Tampa, steps from Tampa Riverwalk and the arena |
| Size (rooms) | 83 guest rooms and suites | 172 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 18 for The Tampa EDITION listing |
| Pools | One heated outdoor pool just outside the lobby with sun loungers | One outdoor pool with pool cabanas (surcharge) and poolside bar |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 | Three restaurants including Lilac, plus four bars/lounges and a cafe |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa (off-site spas listed as nearby options); 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa on site and 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Restored 1927 Jazz Age landmark, waterfront views, wedding venues | EDITION brand luxury, Water Street location, high-profile lifestyle programming |
| Event & meeting space | Nearly 11,500 sq ft across eight indoor/outdoor venues including large lawns and ballrooms | Seven meeting rooms and ballroom spaces (meeting rooms listed: 7) |
| Accessibility & family features | Family-friendly; wheelchair-accessible paths and parking; kids welcome | Multilingual staff, wide accessibility features (wheelchair-accessible rooms/parking/concierge) |
Fenway Hotel sits on St. Joseph Sound near downtown Dunedin, close to the Pinellas Trail and local beaches.
Fenway is a small-city waterfront base for beach access and local walkability.
The Tampa EDITION is located on Channelside in Tampa’s Water Street district, within easy walking distance of the Riverwalk and arena.
The Tampa EDITION is a downtown option for guests who want city attractions and waterfront-adjacent urban access.
Fenway offers 83 rooms and suites with period character and some waterfront views.
Choose Fenway for smaller, characterful rooms in a historic setting.
The Tampa EDITION has about 172 individually decorated guestrooms and a wider selection of suite types.
The Tampa EDITION offers more room variety and larger suite choices typical of a full-service luxury hotel.
Fenway centers dining around HEW Parlor & Chophouse plus a rooftop bar and a speakeasy lounge.
Fenway’s dining leans into local seafood and steakhouse menus with rooftop views and private dining options.
The Tampa EDITION features multiple on-site restaurants and several bars, including Lilac and a coffee shop.
The Tampa EDITION gives more on-site dining choices and late-night bar options typical of a downtown luxury hotel.
Fenway has one heated outdoor pool located just off the lobby with loungers and umbrellas.
Fenway’s pool fits its boutique scale: convenient and heated, but small compared with big-city resorts.
The Tampa EDITION has an outdoor pool with cabanas (surcharge) and a poolside bar.
The Tampa EDITION’s pool area aligns with a downtown luxury lifestyle hotel offering cabanas and service options.
Fenway offers 24-hour fitness facilities and a rooftop bar that serves as a nightlife draw.
Fenway mixes a 24/7 fitness offering with rooftop nightlife but relies on local partners for spa services.
The Tampa EDITION includes a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities, plus multiple bars for nightlife.
The Tampa EDITION emphasizes on-site spa and multiple nightlife outlets suitable for guests wanting full-service luxury amenities.

Fenway Hotel — restored 1927 Jazz Age building on St. Joseph Sound with waterfront views and walkable Dunedin downtown.

The Tampa EDITION — steps from the Tampa Riverwalk, Benchmark International Arena, and Tampa Convention Center.

Fenway Hotel — multiple lawns, ballrooms, and private rooms totaling nearly 11,500 sq ft and diverse outdoor options.

The Tampa EDITION — full-service spa plus three restaurants and four bars across a larger luxury property.
Fenway is closer to Gulf beaches like Caladesi Island and Honeymoon Island; The Tampa EDITION sits on the downtown Channelside waterfront and is not positioned for beach access.
Fenway is explicitly family-friendly and welcomes children of all ages; The Tampa EDITION also allows all ages but is oriented to urban luxury programming.
The Tampa EDITION offers a full-service on-site spa; Fenway does not list an on-site spa and references nearby independent spas instead.
Fenway offers a wider variety of distinctive indoor and outdoor wedding venues and large lawn capacities; The Tampa EDITION provides meeting rooms and ballroom space consistent with a downtown luxury hotel but fewer outdoor lawn options.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·