
Fenway Hotel
Best for intimate waterfront stays, historic character, and small-group events or weddings.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a compact, historic Jazz Age boutique on Dunedin’s waterfront for travelers who want a walkable small-town stay with rooftop views. JW Marriott Tampa Water Street is a large, upscale urban convention-and-leisure hotel in downtown Tampa for business travelers and visitors who want big-hotel facilities and meeting space.
Updated · about 30 miles (≈48 km) apart

Best for intimate waterfront stays, historic character, and small-group events or weddings.

Best for large meetings, downtown location, and full-service hotel amenities including a spa and rooftop terrace.
When Fenway Hotel wins: Choose Fenway if you want a smaller, historic property with a waterfront setting near Dunedin’s downtown, easy access to local trails and beaches, and a hotel with distinctive on-site dining and rooftop hours geared to leisure guests.
When JW Marriott Tampa Water Street wins: Choose the JW Marriott for large meetings or events, wide room variety including water- and city-view options, multiple restaurants and bars, a full-service spa, and easy walking access to the Tampa Convention Center and Riverwalk.
Bottom line: Pick Fenway for boutique character, waterfront Dunedin access, and smaller-scale weddings or leisure stays. Pick JW Marriott Tampa Water Street when you need big-hotel services, event space, and a central Tampa address.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | JW Marriott Tampa Water Street |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small historic boutique with Jazz Age character | Large upscale urban convention and leisure hotel |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront, steps from Pinellas Trail and downtown Dunedin | Downtown Tampa, steps from Tampa Convention Center and Riverwalk |
| Size (rooms) | 83 rooms and suites | 519 rooms |
| Pools | One heated outdoor pool just off the lobby | One outdoor pool (wheelchair-accessible) and pool cabanas (surcharge) |
| Signature restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 speakeasy | Driftlight plus 2 other restaurants and 2 bars/lounges |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site full spa; off-site partner spas listed | Full-service spa and health club on site |
| Event & meeting space | Nearly 11,500 sq ft across 8 indoor/outdoor venues; multiple wedding lawn/ballroom options | 29,000 sq ft conference center with 46 meeting rooms |
| Accessibility & family policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21; not pet-friendly (service animals OK) | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 18; wheelchair-accessible features |
| Parking | Valet parking only (overnight fee applies; complimentary for restaurant/event patrons) | Secured valet parking (surcharge) with in/out privileges |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Yes | |
Fenway Hotel sits on St. Joseph Sound in walkable downtown Dunedin, close to beaches, the Pinellas Trail, and the marina.
Choose Fenway for a small-town waterfront base and easy beach/trail access.
JW Marriott Tampa Water Street is centrally located in downtown Tampa within a short walk of the convention center and Riverwalk.
Choose JW Marriott for a central Tampa location if you want downtown attractions and convention proximity.
Fenway offers 83 rooms and suites in a restored Jazz Age building with a short list of room types.
Fenway’s rooms suit travelers who prefer a smaller, characterful property and waterfront vistas.
JW Marriott lists 519 air-conditioned rooms with a broad set of room types and water- or city-view options.
JW Marriott provides broad room selection for groups, business travelers, and guests who want higher-floor water or harbor views.
Fenway centers its food-and-drink around HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, and the intimate Room 27.
Fenway is good if you want a focused set of high-quality on-site dining venues with a local feel.
JW Marriott offers three restaurants, a coffee shop/café, two bars/lounges, and room service (limited hours).
JW Marriott works well when you want many on-site dining choices and late dining or room service options.
Fenway’s heated outdoor pool sits just off the lobby with a sun deck and loungers.
Fenway’s pool is compact and convenient for guests who prefer a smaller setting close to their room.
JW Marriott has a larger outdoor pool area with cabanas and a rooftop terrace among its notable public spaces.
JW Marriott’s pool and terrace suit guests who want more poolside space and paid cabana options.
Fenway provides 24-hour fitness access and a small set of bars focused on local craft and cocktails.
Fenway covers fitness and evening drinks for couples and small groups but not a full spa program.
JW Marriott includes a health club and a full-service spa on site plus multiple bars for evening options.
JW Marriott is the pick for travelers who prioritize an on-site spa, fitness facilities, and several nightlife options.

Fenway — historic façade, lawn and terrace venues, and several intimate indoor/outdoor event spaces.

JW Marriott — 29,000 sq ft of conference space and 46 meeting rooms for large groups.

Fenway — on St. Joseph Sound with easy access to Dunedin Marina and nearby island beaches.

JW Marriott — full-service spa, multiple restaurants, executive rooms, and large wellness facilities.
Fenway and JW Marriott both welcome children. Fenway is a smaller, family-friendly boutique near beaches; JW Marriott has more on-site facilities and room options for families.
JW Marriott Tampa Water Street — it’s a short walk to the Tampa Convention Center; Fenway is in Dunedin, a drive away.
No — Fenway does not list a full-service on-site spa and instead references nearby partner spas; JW Marriott has a full-service spa on site.
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound with easy routes to nearby barrier-island beaches; JW Marriott is downtown on the water but not a beach resort.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·