
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want historic character, on-site restaurants and event spaces, and a walkable downtown base in Dunedin.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored 1927 Jazz Age boutique hotel on the Dunedin waterfront; read this if you want a historic, walkable base near downtown and waterfront trails. Oceana 202 West is a condo-style beachfront lodging on Treasure Island; read this if you want simple, self-contained beach access on St. Petersburg–Clearwater beaches.
Updated · about 30 miles apart (Dunedin to Treasure Island)

Best for travelers who want historic character, on-site restaurants and event spaces, and a walkable downtown base in Dunedin.

Best for travelers who prioritize direct beach access and a self-contained condo with free self parking.
When Fenway Hotel wins: Choose Fenway for historic character, curated on-site dining and bars (including a rooftop bar), event and wedding facilities, a heated outdoor pool, and easy walking access to Dunedin’s restaurants and the Pinellas Trail.
When Oceana 202 West wins: Choose Oceana 202 West when you want a simple condo on Treasure Island with private balcony, a kitchen, a pool, and immediate access to St. Petersburg–Clearwater beaches for beach days and quick access to John's Pass.
Bottom line: Fenway is a full-service boutique hotel with multiple dining and event options and a waterfront historic setting; Oceana 202 West is a smaller, condo-style beachfront alternative focused on straightforward beach access and self-parking.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | Oceana 202 West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored Jazz Age boutique with historic public spaces and curated dining | Condo-style, straightforward beach lodging focused on self-contained stays |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront on St. Joseph Sound; walkable to downtown and Pinellas Trail | On Treasure Island’s Gulf-facing Gulf Boulevard; on the beach near St. Petersburg Municipal Beach |
| Size | 83 guest rooms and suites | Single condo unit listed (Condo, Multiple Beds (Oceana 202 West)) |
| Who can stay / age policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages allowed; property listing requires primary guest age 25 to book/check in |
| Pools & beach access | One heated outdoor pool by the lobby (sun deck and loungers) | On-site swimming pool and direct beach access a short walk from the unit |
| Rooms | Room, 1 King Bed; Room, 1 King Bed (View); Room, 2 Queen Beds; Suite, 1 Bedroom | Condo, Multiple Beds (Oceana 202 West) — includes a kitchen and private balcony |
| Dining & bars | On-site steakhouse (HEW Parlor & Chophouse), Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 speakeasy | No on-site restaurants listed — self-catering kitchen; nearby dining in Treasure Island and John's Pass |
| Wellness & fitness | 24-hour fitness center on-site; no on-site spa (nearby third-party spas listed) | Not published |
| Parking | Valet parking only for guests (overnight fee applies; complimentary for restaurant patrons) | Free self parking onsite |
| Known for | Historic Jazz Age building, waterfront events and weddings, rooftop views | Beachfront Treasure Island condo with kitchen and balcony |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound in Dunedin with easy walking access to downtown, the Pinellas Trail, and the marina.
Choose Fenway for a walkable historic waterfront base with local dining and trail access.
Oceana 202 West is on Gulf Boulevard in Treasure Island with immediate access to St. Petersburg–Clearwater beaches.
Choose Oceana 202 West for direct beach access and proximity to Treasure Island and John's Pass attractions.
Fenway offers a mix of rooms and suites in a restored historic building.
Fenway gives hotel-style rooms, housekeeping and front-desk service across multiple room types.
Oceana 202 West is a single condo unit designed for self-catering beach stays.
Oceana 202 West suits travelers who want a single condo with kitchen and balcony rather than multiple hotel room options.
Fenway has multiple on-site dining and drinking options from steakhouse dining to a rooftop bar and speakeasy.
Fenway is a better fit if you want several on-site dining and bar options without leaving the property.
Oceana 202 West provides a kitchen in the condo and no on-site full-service restaurants listed.
Pick Oceana 202 West if you prefer self-catering or exploring local beach-district dining.
Fenway provides a heated outdoor pool set just off the lobby with loungers and umbrellas.
Fenway works well if you want a hotel pool plus easy access to nearby beaches by car.
Oceana 202 West lists an on-site swimming pool and is steps from the beach.
Oceana 202 West is better for travelers who prioritize immediate beach access.
Fenway offers on-site fitness and multiple evening bars with rooftop sunset views.
Fenway is a better fit for guests who want on-site fitness and evening bars with views.
Oceana 202 West centers on beach days and local Treasure Island/John's Pass dining and bars.
Oceana 202 West suits guests looking to spend days on the beach and evenings exploring local waterfront dining.

Fenway Hotel — restored Jazz Age architecture, multiple event spaces and wedding venues, and on-site restaurants and rooftop bar.

Oceana 202 West — direct beach access, a private balcony and an in-unit kitchen for self-catering stays.

Fenway Hotel — HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar and Room 27 offer varied on-site dining/drink choices.

Oceana 202 West — free self parking onsite, useful for driving to nearby beaches and attractions.
Oceana 202 West is beachfront and a short walk to St. Petersburg Municipal Beach, so it’s simpler for same-day beach access.
Fenway Hotel — it has HEW Parlor & Chophouse, the Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar and the small Room 27 lounge; Oceana relies on in-unit cooking and nearby restaurants.
Fenway’s outdoor pool is described as heated. Oceana 202 West lists a swimming pool but does not specify whether it’s heated.
Oceana 202 West includes free self parking onsite. Fenway Hotel uses valet parking for guests with an overnight fee; restaurant patrons may get complimentary valet.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·