
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want staffed boutique-hotel amenities: on-site restaurants and bars, event spaces, and a front desk.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored Jazz Age boutique hotel on the Dunedin waterfront with staffed dining, rooftop bar, and event space—good for travelers who want a full-service, historic stay. Oceana 203 West is a condo-style beachfront lodging on Treasure Island for travelers who want a simple self-directed beach stay with a private balcony and onsite pool.
Updated

Best for travelers who want staffed boutique-hotel amenities: on-site restaurants and bars, event spaces, and a front desk.

Best for travelers who want a simple beachfront condo with free self-parking and a private balcony for a beach-focused stay.
When Fenway Hotel wins: choose Fenway if you want a staffed boutique experience with multiple on-site dining options (HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar), event and wedding spaces, a heated outdoor pool, and the historic-Jazz-Age atmosphere of Dunedin.
When Oceana 203 West wins: choose Oceana 203 West if your priority is being literally on Treasure Island’s sand, having a condo layout with a private balcony, and free self-parking for a straightforward beach-first stay without hotel services.
Bottom line: Fenway Hotel is a full-service, historic boutique pick for travelers who value restaurants, bars, and staffed services; Oceana 203 West is a lower-touch, beachfront condo option for travelers focused on beach time and self-catered stays.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | Oceana 203 West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Staffed boutique hotel in a restored 1920s Jazz Age building | Condo-style beach lodging on Treasure Island |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront, near Pinellas Trail and downtown Dunedin | On Treasure Island beachfront (10116 Gulf Boulevard) |
| Size | 83 guest rooms and suites | One condo unit listed (Condo, Multiple Beds (Oceana 203 West)) |
| Ages / check-in minimum | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages welcome; check-in minimum age 25 |
| Pools | One heated outdoor pool with loungers | Swimming pool onsite (listing includes pool) |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 | Not published |
| Spa / wellness | No in-house spa; off-site spas listed as nearby options | Not published |
| Parking | Valet parking only (overnight fee applies; complimentary for restaurant patrons) | Free self parking onsite |
| Known for | Historic Jazz Age hotel with multiple event spaces and rooftop views | Beachfront condo within a short walk of St. Petersburg - Clearwater beaches |
| Key convenience features | 24-hour front desk, 24-hour fitness, mobile check-in/mobile key | Private balcony, elevator, onsite parking |
Fenway Hotel sits on St. Joseph Sound in downtown Dunedin, steps from the Pinellas Trail and local restaurants.
Choose Fenway for walkable waterfront access plus easy links to Dunedin’s downtown and trails.
Oceana 203 West is sited on Gulf Boulevard in Treasure Island—steps from the sand and municipal beaches.
Choose Oceana 203 West if being on the beach and fast access to Treasure Island’s shoreline are your priorities.
Fenway offers 83 guest rooms and suites in a restored historic building with modern amenities.
Fenway’s rooms are hotel-managed with daily service and front-desk support.
Oceana 203 West is listed as a Condo, Multiple Beds (Oceana 203 West) with a private balcony.
Oceana 203 West suits travelers comfortable with a single condo-style unit and self-service arrival.
Fenway has multiple on-site venues for meals and drinks.
Fenway covers on-site dining needs for most guests, including a rooftop bar and steakhouse.
Oceana 203 West’s supplier listing does not publish on-site restaurant or bar details.
Expect to rely on self-catering or nearby restaurants when staying at Oceana 203 West.
Fenway provides one heated outdoor pool near the lobby.
Fenway’s heated pool is convenient but relatively small; beach access requires a short drive.
Oceana 203 West is listed as on the beach and includes an onsite swimming pool.
Oceana 203 West is the better pick for direct beach access and easy beach logistics.
Fenway offers a 24-hour fitness center and a rooftop bar for evening drinks with views.
Fenway combines on-site fitness with a rooftop bar and easy access to Dunedin’s evening scene.
Oceana 203 West listing notes proximity to local beachside restaurants and boardwalks rather than on-site nightlife.
Expect nightlife and wellness options to come from nearby Treasure Island and Madeira Beach venues rather than the property.

Fenway Hotel — multiple on-site venues including HEW Parlor & Chophouse and a rooftop bar.

Oceana 203 West — listed as on the beach with a private balcony and short walk to the sand.

Fenway Hotel — extensive event spaces and wedding packages across multiple indoor and outdoor venues.

Oceana 203 West — free self-parking onsite and email check-in instructions for a low-contact arrival.
Oceana 203 West is listed as on the beach; Fenway Hotel sits on the Dunedin waterfront but is not a beachfront property on the Gulf.
Fenway Hotel has multiple on-site dining and drinking venues (HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar). Oceana 203 West’s supplier listing does not publish on-site restaurant details.
Both properties welcome guests of all ages. Fenway requires a minimum check-in age of 21; Oceana 203 West’s listing shows a check-in minimum age of 25.
Oceana 203 West, as a condo-style unit, is more suited to self-catering and independent stays; Fenway is a staffed hotel with daily services.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·