
Fenway Hotel
Best for intimate, music-tinged historic stays, small-to-mid weddings, and easy access to Dunedin’s waterfront and trails.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored Jazz Age, music-rooted boutique hotel on the Dunedin waterfront; read this if you want an intimate historic stay, rooftop views, and local walkability. The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph Collection is a larger historic luxury resort in downtown St. Petersburg with golf and big-event facilities; read this if you want downtown access, a full-service spa, and on-site golf.
Updated · about 24 km (15 miles) apart

Best for intimate, music-tinged historic stays, small-to-mid weddings, and easy access to Dunedin’s waterfront and trails.

Best for travelers who want downtown St. Petersburg luxury, a full-service spa, on-site golf, and large meeting or event space.
When Fenway Hotel wins: choose Fenway if you want a smaller, boutique historic property with waterfront views, a heated outdoor pool close to the lobby, a rooftop bar with island panoramas, and easy walking access to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail.
When The Vinoy wins: pick The Vinoy if you need resort-scale facilities—multiple restaurants and bars, two outdoor pools, a full-service spa, an on-site golf course and driving range, and a large conference/banquet footprint in downtown St. Petersburg.
Bottom line: both are historic Autograph Collection properties, but Fenway is the better choice for an intimate, locally focused stay in Dunedin; The Vinoy suits guests wanting classic downtown resort amenities, golf, and bigger meeting/event space.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | The Vinoy Resort & Golf Club, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Intimate, Jazz Age boutique with music ties | Larger Mediterranean-style downtown resort and golf club |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront; steps from the Pinellas Trail and downtown Dunedin | Centrally located in downtown St. Petersburg near Vinoy Park and St. Pete Pier |
| Size (rooms) | 83 guestrooms and suites | 356 guestrooms |
| Historic credentials | Jazz Age landmark (opened 1927), restored historic building | Historic luxury resort with longstanding local reputation |
| Pools | 1 heated outdoor pool (just off the lobby) | 2 outdoor pools |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 (speakeasy) | Six restaurants and four bars/lounges, including Paul's Landing and poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site full-service spa; nearby third-party spas listed | Full-service spa on site (massages & facials available) |
| Golf | Nearby public and private courses; not an on-site golf club | Golf course, driving range, lessons and golf caddy services on site |
| Meeting & event space | About 11,500 sq ft across 8 indoor/outdoor venues; strong wedding focus (outdoor lawns & ballroom) | Approximately 74,897 sq ft of meeting space with 21 meeting rooms and a conference center |
| Family policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages welcome (adults-only policy not indicated) |
| Parking & arrival | Valet parking only; overnight fee (approx. $18/night) | Valet parking available (fee applies; in/out privileges noted) |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound with quick access to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail.
Fenway is a small-town waterfront base for beach days and bike or walking access to local Dunedin attractions.
The Vinoy is centrally located in downtown St. Petersburg, close to Vinoy Park and cultural sites.
The Vinoy is the pick for guests who want downtown access and proximity to St. Petersburg’s cultural and waterfront attractions.
Fenway offers 83 rooms and suites in a restored historic building with water views in many rooms.
Fenway’s rooms emphasize historic character and waterfront views in a compact, boutique inventory.
The Vinoy has a much larger room mix (356 rooms) including historic and tower bay-view categories and many accessible options.
The Vinoy offers broader room variety and larger suites for guests who want bay views, balconies, or more space.
Fenway’s food-and-drink program centers on HEW Parlor & Chophouse, a rooftop bar, and an intimate speakeasy.
Fenway is best for a small number of curated dining experiences tied to its historic identity and rooftop views.
The Vinoy provides multiple restaurants and bars—six restaurants and four lounges—covering casual to formal dining.
The Vinoy serves a wider range of dining options on site, useful for guests who prefer not to leave the resort.
Fenway has one heated outdoor pool located just off the lobby with a sun deck.
Fenway’s pool is a cozy, central spot that fits the boutique scale but is not resort-sized.
The Vinoy features two outdoor pools plus a full on-site golf operation.
The Vinoy’s pools and golf give it full-resort facility depth for guests focused on recreation.
Fenway supplies a 24-hour fitness room, rooftop bar nightlife, and local walkable evening options.
Fenway balances fitness and evening drinks with local nightlife; spa services require off-site visits.
The Vinoy includes a full-service spa plus multiple evening bars and downtown nightlife nearby.
The Vinoy is stronger for on-site wellness and a broader nightlife/dining scene in downtown St. Pete.

Fenway — restored Jazz Age architecture, intimate size, and music-rooted programming.

The Vinoy — multiple pools, full-service spa, on-site golf, and many dining venues.

Fenway — varied indoor/outdoor lawns and ballrooms tailored to small-to-mid weddings and historic-photo backdrops.

The Vinoy — large conference center with 21 meeting rooms and tens of thousands of square feet of event space.
Fenway welcomes children of all ages and is well-suited for family stays in Dunedin; The Vinoy also welcomes families but is more of a full-service resort with resort-scale amenities.
The Vinoy has a full-service on-site spa. Fenway does not list an on-site spa and references nearby independent spas.
Yes—both are Autograph Collection properties with historic roots, but Fenway is a smaller Jazz Age boutique while The Vinoy is a larger historic resort.
The Vinoy is better for golfers: it has an on-site golf course, driving range, lessons, and golf services. Fenway is near regional golf courses but has no on-site golf.
Both properties offer valet parking (fees apply). Fenway’s overnight valet fee is published at about $18 per night; The Vinoy lists valet with daily fees and in/out privileges.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·