
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want Jazz Age character, a compact waterfront boutique stay, easy access to Dunedin’s downtown and the Pinellas Trail.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored Jazz Age boutique on Dunedin’s waterfront with rooftop views and a small heated pool—good for travelers who want historic charm, walkable downtown access, and intimate event spaces. The Don CeSar is an iconic, larger Gulf-front resort on St. Pete Beach with a full-service spa and beachfront amenities—read this if you want classic beachfront resort scale, a spa, and more on-site activities.
Updated

Best for travelers who want Jazz Age character, a compact waterfront boutique stay, easy access to Dunedin’s downtown and the Pinellas Trail.

Best for travelers seeking a landmark Gulf-front resort with beachfront access, a larger property with multiple restaurants, and on-site spa services.
When Fenway Hotel wins: choose Fenway if you prioritize historic character, a smaller boutique scale, walkability to Dunedin’s restaurants and breweries, and a rooftop bar with island views.
When The Don CeSar wins: choose The Don CeSar if you want direct Gulf beachfront, a full-service spa, a wider range of on-site recreational options, and larger meeting or event space.
Bottom line: Fenway is the boutique, Jazz Age option for a quieter waterfront stay and local exploration; The Don CeSar is the grand, beach-first resort for a classic St. Pete Beach resort experience.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | The Don CeSar |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Jazz Age boutique, intimate and historic | Grand, iconic Mediterranean-style beachfront resort |
| Location | On St. Joseph Sound in downtown Dunedin, near the Pinellas Trail and marina | On Gulf Boulevard, directly on St. Pete Beach (beachfront) |
| Size (rooms) | 83 rooms and suites | 277 guestrooms |
| Pools / beach | One heated outdoor pool (small, near lobby) | Outdoor pool(s) plus direct access to the beach and beach sun loungers/cabanas |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa (off-site spas nearby) | Full-service spa on property |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 (speakeasy) | 2 restaurants, 1 coffee shop/cafe, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Event & meeting spaces | Nearly 11,500 sq ft across eight indoor/outdoor venues (multiple lawns, ballroom, rooftop) | About 38,000 sq ft of conference/meeting space (large ballroom and meeting rooms) |
| Family friendly | Welcomes children of all ages (not adults-only) | |
| Parking | Valet parking (overnight fee applies; complimentary for diners/event guests) | Self parking and valet available (fees apply) |
| Notable feature | Historic 1927 Jazz Age architecture and front lawn activities | Historic landmark on St. Pete Beach with Mediterranean styling and beachfront services |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound with easy pedestrian access to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail.
Choose Fenway for a walkable small-town waterfront base and access to regional trails and marinas.
The Don CeSar sits directly on St. Pete Beach with immediate Gulf-front access.
Choose The Don CeSar if you want to be steps from the Gulf and spend most of your time on the sand or at pool/beach facilities.
Fenway’s 83 rooms and suites are housed in a restored 1927 building with a few room types and historic character.
Fenway’s rooms emphasize historic detail and a compact, boutique inventory—good for couples and small groups.
The Don CeSar offers a wide mix of room types across a larger resort inventory.
The Don CeSar has more variety and larger inventory—including suites and balcony rooms—typical of a full-service beachfront resort.
Fenway focuses on a compact, locally rooted dining program and an adults-only rooftop bar.
Fenway’s dining emphasizes a destination steakhouse and a rooftop cocktail scene—more intimate than a multi-venue resort.
The Don CeSar provides multiple on-site restaurants and bars with round-the-clock service options.
The Don CeSar’s dining setup supports diverse guest needs across full-day beachfront activities and events.
Fenway has one heated outdoor pool beside the lobby and a rooftop viewing area.
Fenway’s pool and rooftop are well suited to guests who value lounging in a compact, scenic setting rather than large resort pool complexes.
The Don CeSar combines an outdoor pool with direct beach facilities and beach-focused services.
The Don CeSar is focused on beach-and-pool programming suitable for full-day seaside stays and families.
Fenway emphasizes small-scale nightlife, local partnerships, and flexible event spaces across lawns and ballrooms.
Fenway is well suited to intimate weddings, rooftop evenings, and guests who want local nightlife nearby.
The Don CeSar supports larger events, weddings, and on-site wellness with a full-service spa.
The Don CeSar suits travelers who need expansive event facilities and on-site spa/wellness services.

Fenway Hotel — restored 1927 Jazz Age landmark, steps from Dunedin’s downtown, trails, and marina.

The Don CeSar — direct Gulf-front location, beach loungers/umbrellas and cabana options.

The Don CeSar — full-service spa and a wider set of on-site recreational options.

Fenway Hotel — HEW Parlor & Chophouse plus Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar and the speakeasy Room 27.
Both welcome children of all ages. The Don CeSar has more on-site family services and beach facilities; Fenway is smaller and closer to local family-friendly downtown attractions.
No—Fenway does not have an on-site full-service spa; it lists nearby third-party spas for treatments, while The Don CeSar has a full-service spa on property.
For intimate, historic settings choose Fenway (multiple lawns, ballroom, rooftop). For large-scale conferences or big weddings, The Don CeSar offers substantially more conference and ballroom space.
No—The Don CeSar is beachfront on St. Pete Beach; Fenway is waterfront on St. Joseph Sound but does not have an on-site Gulf beach.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·