
Fenway Hotel
Best for travelers who want a full-service historic boutique stay with on-site restaurants, event space, and a heated outdoor pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a restored 1927 Jazz Age boutique hotel in Dunedin offering serviced, waterfront accommodations, onsite dining, a heated outdoor pool, and event spaces. Southern PAG Beach House Bungalows is casual bungalow-style beach lodging in Pass-a-Grille, St. Pete Beach — this guide helps travelers choosing between a historic serviced boutique stay and a low-key beach bungalow stay.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a full-service historic boutique stay with on-site restaurants, event space, and a heated outdoor pool.

Best for travelers who want simple bungalow-style lodging steps from Pass-a-Grille Beach and independent beach access without resort-style services.
When Fenway Hotel wins: Choose Fenway if you want restored historic character, multiple on-site dining and bar options (HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27), a heated outdoor pool, a 24-hour fitness room, and full front-desk service — plus lots of event and wedding space.
When Southern PAG Beach House Bungalows wins: Choose Southern PAG if your priority is being within steps of Pass-a-Grille Beach, having a self-contained bungalow with basic kitchen facilities and free self parking, and access to nearby water activities (sailing, snorkeling, diving) without needing hotel-style services.
Bottom line: Pick Fenway for a serviced, historic boutique stay with dining and event amenities; pick Southern PAG Beach House Bungalows for a casual, stay-by-the-sand bungalow experience in Pass-a-Grille.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | Southern PAG Beach House Bungalows |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored Jazz Age boutique with formal on-site dining and event spaces | Casual bungalow-style beach lodging in Pass-a-Grille |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront on St. Joseph Sound, walkable to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail | In St. Pete Beach (Pass-a-Grille), steps from Pass-a-Grille Beach and Gulf sand |
| Size (rooms) | 83 guest rooms and suites | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages welcome; check-in age 18 per property policy |
| Pools | One heated outdoor pool with sun deck and loungers | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse (steakhouse), Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar (21+), Room 27 speakeasy | No on-site full-service restaurants listed; self-catering kitchen in units and charcoal grills available |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; off-site spas listed nearby; 24-hour fitness center on property | Health or beauty spa nearby listed; no dedicated on-site spa published |
| Known for | Historic landmark, waterfront views, wedding and event venues | Steps from Pass-a-Grille Beach and nearby water activities |
| Parking | Valet parking only (overnight fee for guests; complimentary for restaurant patrons) | Free self parking available onsite (limited spaces) |
| Pet policy | No pets allowed (service animals only) | Pets allowed (pet fee USD 100 per pet per stay; service animals exempt) |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound in downtown Dunedin with easy access to waterfront trails and local attractions.
Fenway is better if you want a combination of waterfront views and walkable town amenities.
Southern PAG Beach House Bungalows sits in Pass-a-Grille, St. Pete Beach, a short walk from Gulf sand and beach attractions.
Southern PAG works when your priority is immediate beach access and a low-key neighborhood setting.
Fenway offers boutique rooms and suites inside a restored 1927 hotel, with a focus on historic character and modern comforts.
Fenway's rooms are for guests who want boutique hotel service and historic ambiance.
Southern PAG offers bungalow units with basic kitchen facilities and garden views, designed for casual beach stays.
Southern PAG is for travelers who want simple, self-catered bungalow accommodations near the beach.
Fenway provides multiple on-site dining and bar venues for casual and more formal meals.
Fenway fits guests who want on-site restaurant options and nightlife without leaving the property.
Southern PAG units are set up for self-catering with outdoor charcoal/gas grills available on-site.
Southern PAG is best if you plan to cook or eat out locally rather than use hotel restaurants.
Fenway features a heated outdoor pool just outside the lobby for guest use.
Fenway is a good choice if you want a hotel pool plus flexible beach access.
Southern PAG's selling point is how close units are to Pass-a-Grille Beach; an on-site pool is not published.
Southern PAG is best for guests whose priority is immediate beach access rather than a hotel pool.
Fenway provides on-site fitness and a rooftop bar for evening views and drinks.
Fenway suits guests who want on-property fitness plus evening dining and rooftop drinks.
Southern PAG emphasizes beachside recreation and nearby water-based activities rather than on-site nightlife or fitness centers.
Southern PAG works for travelers who prioritize daytime beach and water activities over hotel nightlife or gym facilities.

Fenway — HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, and Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar provide multiple on-site dining and drinking options.

Southern PAG — units are steps from Pass-a-Grille Beach and local beach attractions.

Fenway — nearly 11,500 sq ft of event space across multiple indoor and outdoor venues for weddings and meetings.

Southern PAG — bungalow units with kitchens and a published pet fee make it a straightforward option for pet owners.
Both welcome families, but Fenway offers more family-friendly hotel services (front desk, pool, on-site dining). Southern PAG provides direct beach access and kitchen-equipped units, which some families prefer.
No — Southern PAG lists a kitchen in units and grills on-site; there is no full-service restaurant published for the property.
Yes — Fenway has extensive event spaces including lawns, a ballroom, terrace, and pool garden, and offers wedding packages and services.
Fenway does not allow pets (service animals only). Southern PAG allows pets with a published pet fee (USD 100 per pet, per stay).
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·