
Fenway Hotel
Best for guests who want historic character, on-site restaurants and event/wedding facilities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Fenway Hotel is a full-service, historic boutique hotel on Dunedin’s waterfront; read this if you want on-site dining, event space, and a rooftop bar. Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals is a 3‑bedroom rental-style property steps from Treasure Island beach; read this if you want a private beach-area house for a small group.
Updated

Best for guests who want historic character, on-site restaurants and event/wedding facilities.

Best for small groups or families who want a private 3-bedroom rental a few steps from Treasure Island beach.
When Fenway Hotel wins: choose Fenway if you want a staffed, full-service hotel with multiple public dining and bar venues (including a rooftop bar), a heated outdoor pool, fitness access, and a long list of event spaces — all inside a restored Jazz Age landmark.
When Sunshine Lane wins: choose Sunshine Lane if you want a private house-style stay right on Treasure Island (steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches and John's Pass Village) and don’t need on-site restaurants, a hotel front desk, or extensive event facilities.
Bottom line: Fenway is the pick for an amenity-rich, historic hotel experience and events; Sunshine Lane is the pick for simple, rental-style beach access and private-group stays on Treasure Island.
| Category | Fenway Hotel | Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Restored 1920s Jazz Age boutique hotel with waterfront and historic character | Vacation-home, rental-style stay right in the Treasure Island beach neighborhood |
| Location | Dunedin waterfront on St. Joseph Sound; walkable to downtown and the Pinellas Trail | Sunshine Beach area of Treasure Island; steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches and near John's Pass Village & Boardwalk |
| Size | 83 guest rooms and suites | House (3 Bedrooms) |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum age to check in 21 | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age listed as 25 on supplier listing |
| Pools / beach | One heated outdoor pool (guest access) | Steps to public beach; no on-site hotel-style pool listed |
| Restaurants & bars | HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27 | No on-site restaurants listed (self-catering/rental-style) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; nearby third‑party spas listed | Not published |
| Known for | Historic building, event and wedding venues, rooftop sunset views | Immediate beach access and proximity to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk |
| Parking | Valet parking available (overnight fee for guests; complimentary for restaurant patrons) | Limited onsite parking available |
| Check-in / front desk | 24-hour front desk, mobile check-in & mobile key available | No front desk; guests receive an access code and check-in instructions |
| Event space | Extensive: multiple ballrooms, terrace, lawns and rooftop (nearly 11,500 sq ft across venues) | Not published |
Fenway sits on St. Joseph Sound with easy walking access to downtown Dunedin and the Pinellas Trail.
Choose Fenway for a waterfront hotel that’s also a short walk to downtown Dunedin amenities.
Sunshine Lane is a vacation home-style property located on Sunshine Lane in Treasure Island’s beach area.
Choose Sunshine Lane for direct proximity to Treasure Island’s beaches and the boardwalk scene.
Fenway offers 83 guest rooms and suites in a restored Jazz Age building.
Fenway suits travelers who want staffed rooms with hotel services and a range of room types.
Sunshine Lane is listed as a House (3 Bedrooms) vacation home with individually decorated rooms.
Sunshine Lane suits travelers who prefer a private house layout and self-catering flexibility.
Fenway has multiple on-site dining and drinking venues for different occasions.
Fenway is better if you want easy access to varied on-site dining and evening drinks.
Sunshine Lane listing does not show on-site restaurants; expect self-catering and local restaurants nearby.
Sunshine Lane is best if you plan to eat out locally or prepare meals in the rental.
Fenway has a single heated outdoor pool just outside the lobby with sun loungers and umbrellas.
Fenway offers a hotel-style pool plus easy access to nearby beaches and waterfront activities.
Sunshine Lane’s main draw is immediate access to Treasure Island’s beaches rather than a hotel pool.
Sunshine Lane is for travelers prioritizing direct beach access and marine activities over hotel pool facilities.
Fenway provides a 24-hour fitness center and on-site nightlife via rooftop and bars.
Fenway blends workout options with evening drink venues and a walkable local nightlife scene.
Sunshine Lane’s listing highlights nearby water recreation and boardwalk nightlife rather than on-site wellness amenities.
Sunshine Lane appeals to travelers who plan to use local boardwalk nightlife and beach activities instead of hotel wellness facilities.

Fenway — multiple on-site venues including HEW Parlor & Chophouse and the Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar.

Sunshine Lane — steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches and very close to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk.

Fenway — a wide selection of ballrooms, terraces and lawns with substantial event capacity.

Sunshine Lane — a private 3-bedroom house-style rental suited to families or small groups.
Fenway Hotel — it welcomes children of all ages and offers hotel services, a heated pool and family-friendly dining; Sunshine Lane is a private rental that can work well for families but has stairs and limited parking.
Sunshine Lane — the supplier listing notes the house is steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches; Fenway is waterfront on St. Joseph Sound but requires a short drive or trolley ride to main Gulf beaches.
Fenway has multiple on-site venues (HEW Parlor & Chophouse, Parlor Bar, Hi‑Fi Rooftop Bar, Room 27); Sunshine Lane’s listing does not show on-site restaurants.
Fenway has a 24-hour front desk and staffed services; Sunshine Lane is a self-check-in vacation home with an access code and no front desk.
Explore how Fenway Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·